Nahuel Molina’s career has reached a crossroads in Spain. The Argentine right back, who arrived at Atlético de Madrid in 2022 with high expectations after winning the World Cup with Argentina, has now found himself on the fringes of Diego Simeone’s plans. This season has seen Marcos Llorente push him out of the starting lineup, a shift that has raised doubts about Molina’s long-term role in Madrid.
Llorente, naturally more versatile and capable of covering multiple positions, has flourished on the right side of Atlético’s system, forcing Molina into a supporting role. As a result, the 26-year-old has endured reduced minutes in LaLiga and the Champions League, a situation that has left him considering a move elsewhere. With the January window approaching, both Manchester City and Manchester United have identified Molina as a possible reinforcement, setting up a potential Premier League tug of war.
Manchester City’s Search For Defensive Depth
Manchester City, despite their success in recent seasons, have lacked a consistent natural right back to rotate in Pep Guardiola’s demanding system. Kyle Walker remains first choice, but at 34 he cannot be expected to cover every match across four competitions. João Cancelo’s departure left a gap, and while Guardiola has used makeshift options, the need for a reliable specialist has not disappeared.
Molina offers exactly that, a player who is comfortable both defending and pushing forward, with the stamina to cope with City’s high-possession style. His international pedigree with Argentina further boosts his profile. Guardiola values players who can adapt tactically, and Molina fits the bill as someone capable of contributing to City’s intense pressing and build-up play. For the Premier League champions, adding him in January would be about strengthening depth while planning for the future.
Manchester United’s Defensive Struggles
At Old Trafford, the situation is different but equally urgent. Manchester United’s defense has been one of their most inconsistent areas in recent years. Injuries and erratic form from their full-backs have made Erik ten Hag consider reinforcements to steady his backline. Aaron Wan-Bissaka offers defensive solidity but lacks attacking threat, while Diogo Dalot, although more balanced, has not fully convinced.
Molina’s arrival would add competition and give United a more complete option at right back. His ability to deliver crosses and support attacks suits Ten Hag’s system, which demands full-backs who can contribute in both phases of play. Beyond tactics, his experience in LaLiga and at the international level brings maturity that United have often lacked in key defensive moments. For United, Molina would not just be depth, he could be an immediate starter.
City Versus United In The Transfer Battle
The competition between City and United could be fierce. City hold the financial power and the prestige of recent trophies, including the Champions League triumph, to attract any player. The promise of working under Guardiola remains a strong pull. Yet, Molina would face the challenge of competing with Walker and other established names, which might limit his starting chances.
United, on the other hand, could tempt Molina with regular football. At a stage in his career where playing time is crucial, especially with the Argentina national team in mind, that factor may weigh heavily in his decision. The Red Devils can also point to the significance of being part of their rebuilding project, offering him the chance to be a central figure rather than a rotational option.
Atlético De Madrid’s Dilemma
Atlético de Madrid value Molina and have him tied to a contract until 2027, but football realities sometimes force difficult decisions. With Llorente excelling in the role, Molina’s importance has diminished, and a sizeable offer could persuade the Spanish club to cash in. Reports around the club suggest that a fee of 25 to 30 million euros would be considered acceptable, a figure within reach for both Manchester clubs.
Atlético are also aware that reinvesting such money could allow them to strengthen in other positions. Their pragmatic approach to the transfer market has seen them sell players at peak value in the past, and Molina’s current situation may follow that pattern.
What A Premier League Move Offers Molina
For Molina himself, a transfer to England would be an opportunity to revive his trajectory at club level. The Premier League would challenge him with its intensity and physicality, and performing well there would elevate his reputation across Europe. He would also gain exposure in high-profile matches, whether in the league or in continental competitions.
At Manchester City, Molina would be stepping into an environment of stability, structure, and constant pursuit of titles. He would learn from Guardiola and be part of a team that dominates most of its matches. At Manchester United, he would experience a different kind of challenge, one defined by pressure, expectation, and the need to restore a fallen giant to former glory. Both routes offer growth, but they come with different risks and rewards.
The Next Step In Molina’s Career
Nahuel Molina has quickly become one of the most intriguing names ahead of the January window. Atlético de Madrid must decide whether to keep him as a squad option or cash in, while Manchester City and Manchester United prepare to test their resolve with bids.
For the player, the decision will likely come down to prominence. If he chooses City, he joins a winning machine but risks being rotated. If he chooses United, he may gain the regular role he craves, though without the guarantee of immediate success. Either way, Molina stands at a turning point in his career, one that could reshape his path for years to come.
